Unearthing the Dark Side: 8 True Crime Podcasts You Must Listen To

Hosted by the talented Karina Longworth, You Must Remember This is a storytelling podcast that takes listeners deep into the secret and forgotten histories of Hollywood’s first century. With meticulous research and a flair for narrative, Longworth examines the complicated stories behind the films, stars, and scandals that have shaped 20th-century cinema. This heavily-researched work of creative nonfiction showcases a blend of mythology and reality, offering a compelling and educational listening experience. With an average rating of 4.5, it's a fan favorite. You can find it here.

Hollywood Crime Scene dives into the scandals and true tales of crime that involve Hollywood's biggest celebrities. Hosted by Desi Jedeikin and Rachel Fisher, this podcast provides a unique angle on the sordid stories behind the glamor. With an equally impressive rating of 4.5, it’s a go-to for anyone interested in the intersection of fame and crime. Discover more here.

Experience a chilling tale of love gone wrong in Dirty John. This podcast follows Debra Newell, a successful interior designer who finds herself caught in a web of deception after meeting John Meehan, a charming man with a dark past. Hosted by Christopher Goffard from the L.A. Times, the series explores themes of romance, manipulation, and survival, and holds a solid 4.5 rating. All episodes are available for free, with remastered options offered to Wondery+ subscribers. Listen to it here.

If you’re obsessed with true crime, Once Upon a Crime invites you into a realm of captivating storytelling. Each episode provides an engaging narrative of true crime stories that are both fascinating and horrifying. The podcast’s approach combines the allure of fairy tales with the grim reality of crime, ensuring an enthralling listening experience. Although lacking in a published average rating, it is filled with fanatic followers. Find it here.

A Murder On Orchard Street takes listeners through an unsolved homicide case from 2003. This podcast allows listeners to experience the case through various perspectives: the initial suspect, detectives, witnesses, and the victim’s family. With a captivating narrative and a rating of 4.5, it transforms cold-case storytelling into a gripping listening adventure. You can listen to it here.

Sword and Scale ventures into the dark underbelly of crime and highlights the complexities of the criminal justice system. Since its launch in 2014, the podcast has provided raw, uncensored stories involving murder, abduction, and a stunning array of bizarre crimes. It articulates the chilling truths of human nature and societal issues. With the latest average rating of 4.5, it's a standout in true crime podcasting. Dive into it here.

Hollywood & Crime explores notorious crime stories in the heart of Hollywood. From the shocking Cotton Club murder to celebrity trials, each season delves into different tales of betrayal, mystery, and fame. The podcast, boasting an average rating of 4.5, captures the glamorous yet tragic aspects of Hollywood's hidden history. Discover the layers of crime intertwined with celebrity culture here.

Hosted by Phoebe Judge, Criminal is one of the pioneering podcasts focusing on the myriad stories of people who have experienced crime—whether as perpetrators or victims. Named one of the Best Podcasts of 2023 by the New York Times, it continues to draw listeners with its unique storytelling style and engaging narratives. It enjoys a strong average rating of 4.5, making it a must-listen. Start your journey with Criminal here.