CommunityIf He Had Been with Me

Discussion

If He Had Been with Me image

Topic: If He Had Been with Me

On a scale of 1 to 10 how sad is this book??

Fictional profile photo

Fictional Life

 in 

Tearjerker Tales

5 Likes

10 comments

Chandrika D 7 I loved this book so much. I was not expecting the end. I cried so much at the end but idk if it’s that heartbreaking for some people. I guess it depends. One of my favorite books from 2022.

4 Likes

camryn I’m not going to lie I absolutely hated this book and I think by the time I got to the sad part I was numb and just couldn’t wait for the book to be over so I didn’t get emotional at all.

1 Likes

Katelyn Gaskin The book was maybe a 4 on a sad scale. The concept and plot is sad but it wasn’t heartbreaking!

1 Likes

Alexis Dulan I liked this book. I read it a whole ago but from what i remember it was good, brought all the emotions and the ending was sad but tied the book together.

1 Likes

Nancy Kamenyero Not sure about this book, but I’ve now placed it on my To Read list. If you really want a goos cry you have to pick up “You’ve reached Sam”. Tissue box must be close at hand.

Like

Jamille Damasceno this book was 8.5 for me on the heartbreaking scale, i loved it

Like

Katelynn Smith i would say 7-8. i lost it at the ending, and this is the only book that has ever made me sob.

Like

mukerma !! solid 6 tbh

Like

Laure I definitely found it heartbreaking. Such a beautiful book

Like

…. 7-8 super good loved it

Like