Small Town Murder

"Horrible! Nothing but old, tired, stereotypical jokes and making fun of life in small towns. Their constant laughter at their own jokes is so irritating I couldn’t make it through half of the first episode. "

"I love this podcast so much - James does incredible research on the towns and the murders while also being so funny I laugh out loud constantly. It’s more entertaining than TV to me - I literally sit and do puzzles while listening to an episode of this podcast every night"

"Host commentary wasn’t to my liking "

"My very first podcast that I subscribed to. I look forward to it's arrival in my show list each week!"

"I’ve listened to a LOT of true crime podcasts. Serial is the worst I’ve heard. Small Town Murder is by far the best. Features actual research! Facts! Court documents and quotes! Storytellers should don’t come into the story with a predetermined opinion that the guilty is actually innocent because “feelings” and best of all, humor to cut through the dark descriptions of man’s inhumanity against man. "

"Hands down the best podcast!! These two guys keep me laughing!!! SHUT UP AND GIVE ME MURDER!!!!!! "

"I look forward to a new episode every Wednesday!!! This is my favorite podcast!!!"

"It can be quite boring for some people because the go through the towns history to paint a picture first. I really like it. They are comedians and make jokes but I honestly really really like it! If you don’t like the beginning part of the towns history just skip the first 30 ish minutes to get the story."

"Comedy and murder? What more could you want. A tasteful way to include humour into wild and crazy murder cases, James and Jimmy keep you laughing and engaged, wanting to know more. "

"This podcast is just a good time. If you don’t like comedy with your murder I wouldn’t recommend but if you do this one’s a 10/10. The hosts are actual comedians and best friends that make actually funny commentary. Most comments are about mediocre cops and lackluster investigation skills with breaks for fun banter or especially hostile judgement. None of the comments are made to be disrespectful to the victim of the crime or their surviving families. They’re assholes but they’re not scumbags."