10 Must-Listen Supernatural Podcasts That Will Haunt Your Dreams

Delve into the dark historical tales presented in Lore, an award-winning podcast that has also become a successful TV show and book series. Each episode uncovers mysterious creatures, tragic events, and unusual places from the annals of history. Host Aaron Mahnke captivates listeners with stories so compelling that they often blur the lines between truth and fiction. The chilling reality presented in Lore makes it clear that sometimes, what actually happened is far scarier than any fictional tale. Listen here

Join the spirited duo of Em and Christine every Sunday as they blend true crime and paranormal stories in And That's Why We Drink. This podcast is perfect for those who enjoy a chill atmosphere paired with chilling tales. Grab your favorite beverage—be it wine or milkshakes—and dive into ghost stories and true crime narratives that showcase the world's darker side. Their engaging repartee makes the eerie topics approachable and entertaining. It’s a thrilling and terrifying experience rolled into one! Listen here

Step into the fictional world of Radio Rental, where real-life horror stories unfold in an 80’s video rental store. Hosted by the eccentric Terry Carnation, played by Rainn Wilson, this inventive podcast combines documentary storytelling, dark comedy, and spine-chilling narratives. With the unique setup and occasional humorous twist, Radio Rental transforms ordinary life into extraordinary paranormal adventures that stay with you long after listening. Listen here

Embark on a psychological journey in The Black Tapes, a serialized docudrama hosted by journalist Alex Reagan. The podcast unravels veils of mystery surrounding a series of tape recordings linked to supernatural events and figures. As Reagan searches for the truth about her subject’s haunted past, listeners are treated to a gripping narrative that explores belief, the paranormal, and the ghosts of unresolved history. It's a compelling exploration of the unknown that invites you to ponder your own beliefs. Listen here

Dark and foreboding, The NoSleep Podcast offers a chilling collection of original horror stories complemented by atmospheric music. This award-winning anthology series is designed to envelop you in fear, transporting you into realms filled with spine-tingling narratives that are hard to shake off. With high production values and evocative storytelling, it promises to keep you awake long into the night. Listen here

Hosted by Dan and Lynze Cummins, Scared To Death serves up spine-chilling horror stories that dig deep into the supernatural realm. Not only does Dan share terrifying tales that send shivers down the spine, but Lynze also contributes with eerie accounts submitted by fans. Their dynamic approach—a blend of genuine scares and light-hearted commentary—creates a unique listening experience that will thrill horror fans. Plus, be sure to tune in for their mini-series, Nightmare Fuel, for an extra dose of fright! Listen here

Starring Tessa Thompson, The Left Right Game follows an idealistic journalist as she dives into the supernatural lore surrounding a seemingly innocuous game. However, the seemingly harmless pastime quickly spirals into a chaotic and terrifying adventure. This gripping podcast merges storytelling with a visual element that challenges perceptions of reality, leaving listeners captivated and on the edge of their seats! Listen here

Get ready for a supernatural thriller with Bridgewater, where folklore professor Jeremy Bradshaw becomes embroiled in mysteries from his past. As he tries to unravel the truth, listeners are taken on an immersive journey with suspense, rich character development, and thought-provoking themes. With skilled narration by Misha Collins and others, this podcast invites you to ponder the possibilities of rewriting history through folklore. Listen here

Join co-hosts Scott and Forrest on a captivating exploration of the world's mysteries with Astonishing Legends. This podcast dives into peculiar phenomena and enthralling legends, unraveling stories that make our reality seem larger than life. With a wealth of episodes reaching over millions of downloads, they invite listeners to embrace their curiosity about the inexplicable. An enigmatic mix of education and entertainment awaits every listener! Listen here

Prepare to delve into the mysteries of our world with Unexplained, a bi-weekly podcast dedicated to exploring strange events that elude rational explanation. By combining narrative storytelling with historical insights, the podcast offers a haunting experience that keeps you engaged and questioning your understanding of reality. Each episode is a captivating journey into the unknown where belief can seem as solid as fact. Listen here